ARTICLE DOWNLOAD

On Historical Dynamics by P. Turchin

10$
ARTICLE DOWNLOAD

On Historical Dynamics by P. Turchin

10$

Alessandro Maini 

Abstract

The book Historical Dynamics: Why States Rise and Fall by P. Turchin contains one of the first efforts to apply basic system dynamics (SD) to the analysis of the past human history. The present review paper focuses on the consistency and solidity of the mathematical modelling advanced in the book. It is found that all the models used in the book are based on human-centred drivers only, and lack any connection with the physical world. Moreover, all of the models are flawed, some by omission (i.e. the discussion presented in the book omits relevant trends that can be tested against historical data) and some by structure (i.e. they are mathematically wrong). These findings imply that the mathematical conclusions of the book do not support the interpretation of historical events, and this paper wants to alert the researchers about the pitfalls that must be faced when dealing with the application of SD to human history modelling.

Only units of this product remain
Year 2020
Language English
Format PDF
DOI 10.1007/s41247-019-0063-x